More flak from foreign observers
Posted by: Avigail Olarte | May 18, 2007 at 6:54 pm
Filed under: 2004 Electoral Fraud, 2007 Elections, In the News
(This report was written by PCIJ interns Glenys Banal and Luis Liberato)
TWO teams of international observers today expressed disappointment with the recently held midterm elections.
The 16-member team of the Compact for Peaceful Elections said a sense of resignation over the electoral process, fraud, and violence dominated the conduct of the 2007 elections.
The 27 observers of the People’s International Observers’ Mission agreed, stating that the significant number of disenfranchised voters, vote-buying, deadly election-related violence, direct intimidation of the armed forces, the suspicious absence and abandonment of duties of Commission on Elections (Comelec) officials, and the overt coercion by candidates of powerful political clans ran contrary to the Palace’s statement that Filipino voters “cast their ballot, free of coercion and according to their own will.”
Another delegation of foreign observers from the Asian Network for Free Elections (ANFREL) earlier reported similar findings of widespread violence, blatant vote-buying, and election irregularities in the Muslim Mindanao provinces.
Read the report of the People’s International Observers’ Mission here and the observations of the Compact for Peaceful Elections here.
Lawrence Surendra of Compact said factors such as “the failure to enforce election laws, the weakness of the party system, and legal loopholes” make the polls prone to fraud and violence.
According to Compact, which had four teams deployed to Pampanga, Nueva Ecija, Negros, Cotabato City, Bicol Region, and the Autonomous Region of Muslim Mindanao, there were 144 recorded cases of election-related violence and 21 incidents of fraud.
Vote-buying, the presence of “flying” voters, delaying tactics in the canvassing of votes, death threats against supporters of certain groups were also widespread.
Meanwhile, People’s IOM condemned the perpetuation of political dynasties.
“Families running a country raises a lot controversy,” said Australian Gill Boehringer. “Clans (use) manipulation and fraud,” added Larry Emery, who was sent to observe the elections in Guimba, Nueva Ecija.
The group reported that rivalries between clans result into violence and reprisals, adding that the use of private armed groups made the it difficult, if not impossible, to conduct a free and honest elections.
It also cried foul over the labeling and the use of fraud, harassment, and force against legitimate party-lists.
“The killings of the leaders and members of these party-list groups are clear evidence of criminal attempts by state forces to drive these groups from the electoral arena and deprive the people of their democratic right to elect their own representatives,” the group said.
Also, there have been reports that the military had campaigned against Bayan Muna, Gabriela, and Anakpawis, telling residents that these groups are fronts of the Communist Party of the Philippines-New People’s Army.
“The progressive party-list groups were considered evil and should not be voted. They were even running a film showing the evils of voting for the ‘enemy,’” Boehringer reported.
President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo last Tuesday ordered the filing of at least 20 cases against those responsible for extrajudicial and election-related killings. The order was issued after election observers raised concern over the violence that marred last Monday’s elections.
For its recommendations, People’s IOM said major changes in the electoral procedures should be instituted; elections should be insulated from the partisanship of government agencies and public officials; the culture of fraud engendered by traditional politicians must be altered; effectively halt the military’s interventionist role; reinforce the party-list system of representation; and have an independent and serious investigation on the conduct of the 2004 national elections to resolve the question of the legitimacy of the President’s mandate.
Compact also had similar recommendations, stressing that the electoral process should be done in an environment free of intimidation and harassment.
It recommended, among others, the urgent implementation of the Automation Law; an improved and more efficient Comelec; a more efficient voters’ registration process and the use of voter’s ID to avoid the disenfranchisement of voters; and clearer guidelines for the conduct of elections in hot spots.
feel free to leave a comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.












5 people have left comments
[...] Yesterday, a delegation of foreign observers, the People’s International Observers’ Mission, decried the labeling, use of fraud, and force against legitimate party-lists and opposition candidates. [...]
[...] Yesterday, a delegation of foreign observers, the People’s International Observers’ Mission, decried the labeling, use of fraud, and force against legitimate party-lists and opposition candidates. [...]
“FOREIGN OBSERVERS MAY HAVE OBSERVED THE NEGATIVE ELECTION PRACTICES THAT HAVE PERSISTED IN EVERY ELECTORAL PROCESS WE HAVE SINCE THE TEJEROS CONVENTION.
NAKAKAHIYA TALAGA TO”
[...] Ellen Tordesillas links to an article which mentioned the remark made by a foreign observer about feeling more secure in Afghanistan than in southern Philippines. Inside PCIJ has a transcript of the report of foreign observers. The article notes the following: “The 27 observers of the People’s International Observers’ Mission stated that the significant number of disenfranchised voters, vote-buying, deadly election-related violence, direct intimidation of the armed forces, the suspicious absence and abandonment of duties of Comelec officials, and the overt coercion by candidates of powerful political clans ran contrary to the Palace’s statement that Filipino voters cast their ballot, free of coercion and according to their own will.” [...]
[...] Ellen Tordesillas links to an article which mentioned the remark made by a foreign observer about feeling more secure in Afghanistan than in southern Philippines. Inside PCIJ has a transcript of the report of foreign observers. The article notes the following: “The 27 observers of the People’s International Observers’ Mission stated that the significant number of disenfranchised voters, vote-buying, deadly election-related violence, direct intimidation of the armed forces, the suspicious absence and abandonment of duties of Comelec officials, and the overt coercion by candidates of powerful political clans ran contrary to the Palace’s statement that Filipino voters cast their ballot, free of coercion and according to their own will.” [...]