Recent Comments

  • vonjobi: wow, congratulations! kelan ang trip? i hope i'll be around when you come. had a good time with diosa last...
  • Keith Bacongco: Knowing Nograles and his Big Boss...garapalan na lang talaga.
  • Vinia Datinguinoo Mukherjee: Congratulations, PCIJ! Mabuhay kayo!
  • Lead Philippines: But without credible mass media there, what is left to protect the people..?
  • vonjobi: it's juned sOniDo.

Live Shoutbox

Latest Message 5 months ago
  • hopeless_race : Lets not just focus sa mga malversation of funds, sa mga overpricing..ating pagtuunan ng atensyon ang diskarte ng mga politiko na umuutang ng bilyon bilyon sa gobyerno."Small time" ang ibang pamamaraan ng pangungurakot kumpara sa pag-utang sa gobyerno ng bilyon na tunay ngang masasabing "pinaka big-time" at wala pang sabit.
  • hopeless_race : Mukhang tikom ang bibig ng lahat pagdating sa diskarte ng mga politiko sa pagutang ng mga bilyon bilyon sa gobyerno na tinatakbuhan. Itong pamamaraan na ito ang tunay na kumakain ng malaking porsyento ng ating national budget batay na din sa sinasabi ng world bank.
  • hopeless_race : Pakisilip naman po ang mga utang ni Villar sa BSP, ang mga utang nila RAMON JACINTO, RONNIE ZAMORA, JOE DE VENECIA at madami pang ibang mga pulitiko. Iilan lamang yan sa mga nababanggit sa balita na may mga malalaking utang sa gobyerno.
  • hopeless_race : Nagmimistulang "small time" lamang ang malversation of funds kumpara sa laki ng kinakamal ng mga umuutang sa gobyerno. At ito ay malinaw na natatakbuhan dahil hindi nga naman pwede makulong ang may-ari ng kumpanya sa pagkaka-utang lamang. Tunay na mga tuso at magagaling sa batas itong mga politiko natin. Masasabi ko na malamang lahat ng mga politiko ganito ang diskarte...wala pang kulong.
  • hopeless_race : PCIJ pkitingnan naman po ang mga gaya ni Villar na my malaking utang sa Gobyerno pero tinatakbuhan. Magtatayo ng kumpanya at uutang ng bilyon bilyon sa gobyerno ng walang balak bayaran. Tunay ngang walang nakukulong sa utang...ito ang prinsipyo ginagamit ng mga politiko ntin kaya nakakapagtaka kung san napupunta ang daang bilyong pera ng gobyerno.
  • hopeless_race : Sana itreat naman po ng media ang hacienda luisita at mendiola massacre na parang MAGUINADANAO MASSACRE. Ipublicized ang mga katotohanan at ipakita sa tao ang karumaldumal na pinaggagawa sa mga farmers dun. Untouchable po ba sila cory at danding at hindi magawang batikusin ng media about these two massacres?
  • hopeless_race : Kapag napaguusapan ang mendiola at hacienda luisita massacre ay parang walang nangyari at parang hindi big deal. Anu po ba ang pinagkaiba ng dalawang nabanggit na massacre sa maguindanao massacre?
  • hopeless_race : Its sad that we pinoys are blind to the fact of what had happened in mendiola and hacienda luisita. Ang tanong..bakit ang media ay hindi manlang matackle ang ganitong usapin? Takot ba sila kay cory at danding?
  • hopeless_race : Wilkins" brand, for P1.4 billion.-1999 Sugarland Multi-Food Corp. for P2.9 billion 2001- Purefoods Corp P7 billion P60 billion Coca-Cola ... See More 2002- Cosmos Bottling Corp. from RFM Corp. for P14.1 billion October 2008- GSIS' shares in Meralco worth PHP30 Billion. December 2008- country's biggest oil refiner, Petron Corporation. international company shopping spree: Australian boutique brewer J. Boag and Son for A$96 million in 2000. $97 million for Thai Amarit Brewery Ltd $35.5 mi
  • hopeless_race : Gud am..glad to be back.
  • jr_lad : rip mr. alecks pabico. you'll be greatly missed!
  • sevens21 : Dati input mo lng name at SSS ID makukuha mo agad STATIC INFO...
  • sevens21 : tawag ka sa HOTLINE nila walang ANSWER grrr we need pa namn ng static info SSS Gising!!!
  • sevens21 : Gawa naman po kayo ng article about SSS. Pangit ng site nila dali ma blocked ng account
  • guest_899 : we must check the background of each potential candidates to avoid having another big mistake like GMA
  • guest_899 : congratulations to PCIJ, more power and God Bless !
  • jazzymuver : how did Arroyo swallow that kind of things!! how come that she just spend the money our countrymen for her own sake!!
  • guest_3664 : i would be glad if u can include the investigation of the manner public officials announce infra projects as per COA regulation. It is frustrating to see their faces on the tarpaulin instead of the prescribed information like name of project, date of implementation,amount of contract, source/s of fund, among other things. This is very rampant here in Marikina. Thanks and more power on your noble endeavors. We need people like you to have make our country great again.
  • jhanz_08 : im making research on R.A 9136...with rgards to the privatization of NPC..could someone out there can let me understand more bout this matter?why was monopoly dismantled?email me..jhanycem@yahoo.com...thanks much
  • erika marie : P.S.:) my paper is due next week and i do hope someone could provide me these reports coming from reliable resources :) thank you ulit. :)
  • erika marie : P.S. :)
  • guest_4275 : i am currently doing a study regarding political killings in the philippines. could someone out there please send me human rights reports under Aquino and Ramos administration. you could send it at my email: erikamariet@yahoo.com your response would surely be very much appreciated. thank you everyone. god bless.
  • guest_4275 : i am currently doing a study for my paper regarding political killings in the philippines. i noted that there are no human rights reports during the Aquino and Ramos administration. could someone out there please send me reports regarding these matter? i do hope these reports came from reliable resources :) you could send it in my email; erikamariet@yahoo.comyour response would surely be appreciated. thanks everyone. god bless.
  • jayson bourne : gusto ko po maging member ng PCIJ, panu po ba? may application po ba? sana mapadalhan nyo ako ng info sa email ko... www.jboxpenshoppe@yahoo.com
  • jayson bourne : cory is OK, but kris & Noynoy sensationalize masyado...
  • guest_9891 : LABAN pa rin!
  • meow : boycotts worked during marcos years. how about doing it now against the businesses of the con-ass congressmen?
  • meow : aside from 168, what other establishments can we boycott that belong to the arroyos and their cronies?
  • Jalenack : Your shoutbox is blank. Add a message!

You must be a registered user to participate in this chat



Miscellaneous

Feeds


Bolante deportation looms

Posted by: Alecks P. Pabico | June 4, 2008 at 6:59 pm
Filed under: 2004 Electoral Fraud, Cross Border, Governance, In the News

THE prospects of being deported to the Philippines loomed large for former agriculture undersecretary Jocelyn ‘Joc-Joc’ Bolante after the Board of Immigration Appeals in Chicago denied his claim for asylum and withholding of removal from the U.S. under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) in June last year.

Jocelyn 'Joc-joc' Bolante [photo courtesy of Rotary website]Bolante, who is accused of masterminding the P728-million fertilizer fund scam allegedly diverted to Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo’s presidential campaign in 2004, however filed a petition for a review of his case with the Federal Court of Appeals. The decision on Bolante’s appeal is expected within this month or July after oral arguments were heard last February 11, 2008, disclosed University of the Philippines law professor Harry Roque.

Roque, who is currently in New York to attend the Assembly of State Parties of the International Criminal Court at the United Nations, has obtained a copy of the decision of the immigration appeals board that he furnished the PCIJ.

In its June 25, 2007 decision, the board upheld the ruling of the Chicago Immigration Court dismissing Bolante’s asylum request on the ground that he was suffering from a “genuine fear of political persecution.” The board agreed with the findings of Immigration Judge George Katsivalis, who noted that:

  • respondent (Bolante) did not present any evidence of past mistreatment or harm;
  • the evidence revealed that there were presently no charges pending against the respondent with regard to the fertilizer scam and only an arrest warrant for his failure to appear and testify before the Senate;
  • his prosecution was clearly not a pretext for persecution as he was never sought out for arrest until he failed to comply with numerous subpoenas.

Read the decisions of the Board of Immigration Appeals and the Immigration Court of Chicago.

“For all the reasons noted by the Immigration Judge, we agree that respondent failed to establish that he suffered past persecution nor a well-founded fear of persecution on account of his imputed political opinion,” declared the board.

It also said that “prosecution for the violation of a law of general applicability is not persecution, unless the punishment imposed is for invidious reasons.”

The board similarly rejected the testimony of the witnesses Bolante presented in court, including himself, finding them not material and credible.

Bolante’s son Owen claimed that he received “unfulfilled threats and text messages” from unknown persons. Bolante also argued that a bounty has been set for his capture, that radical groups may attempt to capture him, and that government authorities cannot protect him from these groups.

Department of Agriculture Undersecretary Felix Montes testified that Bolante could be harmed if he will be returned to the Philippines as “a lot of people are out to get (him)” and “who might use him as a tool to get at the President.”

Without elaborating, retired Major General Rodolfo Estrellado, Bolante’s colleague at the Rotary Club, also said the same thing, and even made mention of the fact that there have been “755 (cases of) political killings in the Philippines that have remained unsolved.”

The board, however, noted that Montes, who is similarly implicated in the fertilizer funds scam, “remains unharmed in the Philippines and similarly not charged.” His testimony, according to Judge Katsivalis was also “lacking in detail and entirely speculative.”

It also affirmed the judge’s ruling that “unfulfilled threats” do not support a claim of past or future persecution, and that there was no evidence presented regarding the existence of a bounty.

As to the political unrest raised by Estrellado, the board said that dangerous conditions as random isolated criminal acts, civil strife, and general unrest in the alien’s homeland do not necessarily rise to the level of persecution in asylum cases.

Bolante has been in detention since his arrest on July 7, 2006 upon arriving in Los Angeles owing to a cancelled visa. He was told by a U.S. immigration officer that the U.S. Embassy in Manila revoked his B1/B2 visa in light of the arrest warrant issued by the Senate for his role in the fund scam.

Roque, who along with fellow UP law professors Merlin Magallona and Raul Pangalangan, filed an amicus brief in August 2006 in an effort to convince the immigration court not to grant Bolante’s request for political asylum, noted that both the courts’ decisions did adopt their arguments and the attached annexes, including copies of the Senate and Commission on Audit reports on the fertilizer funds scam.

But while pleased with the recent decisions, Roque expressed concern regarding the arguments raised by Bolante’s lawyers in his petition for review pending with the federal appellate court. As proof of his claim of persecution, Bolante’s lawyers have argued that the Ombudsman has yet to file criminal charges against him despite the Senate’s issuance of a warrant of arrest.

This, claimed Roque, is an indication of a “clear collusion” between Ombudsman Merceditas Gutierrez and Bolante. “Apparently, her inaction is not only to prevent the filing of a criminal complaint that can be the basis for extraditing Bolante. It is also being used as proof of persecution in favor of Bolante,” he said.

Roque likewise expressed alarm about Montes’s testimony. “First, it bothers me that no less than a Usec of the DA could lie brazenly about the Senate persecuting Bolante. As Usec, he is subject to the qualified political agency doctrine which means that his pronouncements, when given in official court proceedings, are deemed as declarations of the President herself.”

He recommended that Montes and Estrellado be charged in the U.S. for false testimony.

For further background on Bolante’s immigration case, see also:



19 people have left comments

Hoohuummm!!!

Persecution is the medium of the strong to torment the weak. Undersecretary Bolante hardly belongs to the weak class if the accusation is true that he manipulated the fertilizer’s fund and funnel it to GMA’s election fund.

I just hope that the people wanting him so bad in the Philippines so he can answer for his fund diversion are doing it for noble cause and not for the highly desired sound bytes and mileage that can sustain them to the 2010 elections.

jcc wrote on June 4, 2008 - 10:49 pm | Visit Link

Alecks, I referred to Undersecretary Bolante as a he because of the photo in the post. I just hope that he is really a he despite the name Jocelyn.

jcc wrote on June 4, 2008 - 11:05 pm | Visit Link

Jock-jock may explain the root of rice crisis in the Philippines…tsk tsk tsk.

Naalala ko tuloy ang mga sinabi ng father ko…harapin mo ang consequences ng mga kalokohan mo, ginawa mo yan, kaya dapat panagutan mo…pero kung nasa tama ka, di kita pababayaan.

nosi balasi wrote on June 5, 2008 - 2:21 pm | Visit Link

see GMANews.TV below…wala nang patawad…education, fertilizer, etc…ngayon naman…wow ha…ober na ober na yan…different case but similar…Jock-Jock was a President of Rotary Club and at the same time Agriculture Undersecretary…then Samie Lim, a PCCI President and at the same time as appointed private sector Tourism Chief…both came from a very influential business organizations, and appointed by Malacanang…i hope that their appointment was just based on their knowledge and experiences that will help our Govt to achieve a strong Republic and not for the personal interest of the sitting President. tsk tsk tsk

GMANews.TV - Wednesday, June 4

MANILA, Philippines- An influential business group wants the government to privatize a handful of the country’s major tourist spots, a move that they said will ensure the preservation of the areas.

Philippine Chamber of Commerce and Industry president and appointed tourism private sector chief Samie Lim said the Philippine Tourism Authority should sell some of its major assets which have the potential to become even more attractive to both foreign and local visitors.

Among those spots that should be privatized are the Banaue Rice Terraces, Picnic Grove and Palace in the Sky in Tagaytay City, and Burnham Park in Baguio City.

Another tourist spot that could be privatized, Lim said, is a beach resort in La Union that is not being managed well.

Lim said that by having private groups to manage the destinations, the country could have a better chance of attaining its goal of hitting some 10 million tourists arrivals by 2010.

Department of Tourism (DOT) data showed the country accommodates an average of 3 million tourists annually.

Apart from this proposal, Lim is also raising the posibility of privatizing all the government-controlled duty-free shops.

?These shops could even earn more if placed under a private management,” he said. - GMANews.TV

nosi balasi wrote on June 5, 2008 - 3:20 pm | Visit Link

Yes, jcc, he is male with a feminine name. But that, as you can see, is not the bigger anomaly here. :-)

Alecks P. Pabico wrote on June 5, 2008 - 3:34 pm | Visit Link

Alecks,

Thanks for clearing this one up. But speaking of a greater anomaly, you would be amazed to find that:

In French, particularly in Québec,the spelling “Jocelyn” is exclusively male. The female counterpart is spelled “Jocelyne”.

Undersecrtary Bolante, I might add, have a better chance in seeking political asylum in France :)

jcc wrote on June 6, 2008 - 6:23 am | Visit Link

Who is Jocjoc Bolante?

He was an undersecreatary in the Department of Agriculture during and before the 2004 presidential elections. A rotarian and a congressman wanabe.

What is the Jocjoc Bolante Case?

He was instrumental in using the people’s money (supposed to be for use in buying fertilizers to be given to farmers). It was alledged that the funds were diverted to Gloria Arroyo’s campaign kitty. During the senate hearing it was more or less established that some things were fishy.

Before he could be made to answer, he fled the country. Now he’s in an American jail pending deportation. He’s applied for a visa to stay in the US. So far he’s been denied.

What is the government doing with the case?

The senate has investigated the case and the findings were forwarded to the Ombudsman. The Ombudsman (The First Gentleman’s classmate, has been sitting on the case for a long time.

Additional Information from Newsbreak

An ongoing saga first exposed during the 2004 campaign period and which resurfaced at the height of the impeachment attempt against the President, the fertilizer scam has crossed the Pacific with the arrest of its supposed main architect, former agriculture undersecretary Jocelyn “Joc-Joc” Bolante.

Arrested at the Los Angeles International Airport in July last year for a canceled visa, Bolante is now fighting deportation proceedings in a US court, even as he seeks political asylum there, claiming that the opponents of the President wanted him dead. His court troubles began when he snubbed repeated Senate subpoenas for him to shed light on the P728-million fertilizer fund allegedly distributed to Arroyo’s allies during the 2004 election.

A member of the Makati Rotary Club like the First Gentleman, Bolante was Arroyo’s first appointee to the agriculture department, which she headed for a time after she assumed the Presidency in 2001.

It was Bolante who distributed the fertilizer fund to local allies of the President, supposedly to subsidize farmers. But a Senate investigation showed that the funds were misused for political purposes. The Senate has recommended the filing of plunder charges against Bolante, as well as former Agriculture Secretary Luis Lorenzo.

Farmers have claimed that not one centavo trickled down to them. “The farm inputs and implements program is a premeditated, systematic and grand agricultural theft. In the words of farmers and taxpayers, the fertilizer scam is the rape of the nation,” the Senate finding said.

Reference: http://arroyocorruption.pbwiki.com/Joc+Joc+Bolante+Case

nosi balasi wrote on June 22, 2008 - 10:02 am | Visit Link

Rotary Club, another name for MAFIA.

jcc wrote on June 22, 2008 - 9:47 pm | Visit Link

jcc, is that a fact or just your opinion?

jr_lad wrote on June 23, 2008 - 2:36 am | Visit Link

jr_lad

where protectionism and spoils distribution are made on the basis of membership in the organization (FG a rotarian, Bolante another rotarian apppointed as Agriculture Secretary) the orgnization’s legitimacy becomes suspect. if you are are an honorable member of that organization, it is my opinion that you bail out from the organization unless like others, you might be waiting for the spoils too.

:)

jcc wrote on June 23, 2008 - 4:48 am | Visit Link

To be fair, there were some officers and members of the Rotary Club who did issue critical open letters back in 2006, urging Bolante to come out and tell the truth behind the fertilizer funds scam. One letter-writer, Harvey Keh, even questioned the Rotary Club’s silence on the issue.

See this post.

Alecks P. Pabico wrote on June 23, 2008 - 11:07 am | Visit Link

Alecks, jr_lad;

Rotary, is a big business/professional club. To promote its business or profession it has to act as an effective lobby group to promote its members’ careers and/or business. The best way to do it is to align itself with the dispensers of power, the government, and other big businesses. The government or big businesses have to look for a stable allies in the laps of these professional groups, of which Rotary club is one and whose membership are the moneyed group of the society. Assured of unabashed loyalty from these professional groups, the government preference to distribute the spoils and other government largesse, is quite predictable.

That as an association, the Rotary had kept silence about the Joc-Joc scandal is understandable, because as a club, it has to look for greater benefit of its membership and not the benefit of the greater majority of the people as epitomized in its objectives and goals:

“the development of fellowship and understanding among its members; the promotion of community endeavors; the maintenance of high standards in business and professional practices”.

So the emphasis is development x xx of members, x x x high standards in business professional practices, which is another way of saying “making more money for its members”.

That Rotarian Mr. Harvey Keh, had expressed his disgust over the silence of the Rotary Club over the Joc-Joc affair should not be seen as a vindication of the club’s professionalism, but as an indictment of the club’s of decay as seen by one of its honest member.

jcc wrote on June 23, 2008 - 11:42 pm | Visit Link

jcc, correct me if i’m wrong, they way i understand it, the rotary club is composed of different groups just like the toastmaster’s club. my wife was able to attend an all women’s group lately. you’re right, the group members are highly educated and into business. the group of mike A. & joc-joc B. must be one powerful group among rotarians.

That as an association, the Rotary had kept silence about the Joc-Joc scandal is understandable, because as a club, it has to look for greater benefit of its membership and not the benefit of the greater majority of the people as epitomized in its objectives and goals… jcc

i think you’re right on this one jcc. they have their own agenda the reason for the group’s silence on bolante.

jr_lad wrote on June 24, 2008 - 3:19 am | Visit Link

thanks jr_lad. i just hope that whatever views we have here, will not be considered as “voices in the wilderness”, but as indicators that certain sectors of our society are awake and willing to put their message across without fear or favor.

jcc wrote on June 24, 2008 - 5:58 am | Visit Link

jcc, jr_lad…just like the masonry…though they knew there was a mistake done by one of their member as long as the mistake is outside their brotherhood…is not a mistake…instead they will protect their brother from harm. a part of their doctrine…brotherhood is second to God…while Family, Relatives or Friends, etc…is below their brotherhood.

nosi balasi wrote on June 24, 2008 - 1:21 pm | Visit Link

nosi_balasi;

well-put and incisive as well.

jcc wrote on June 24, 2008 - 9:24 pm | Visit Link

[...] appeals board upheld the ruling of the Chicago Immigration Court which dismissed Bolante’s asylum request on the [...]

The Daily PCIJ » Blog Archive » U.S. Court of Appeals rejects Bolante asylum petition wrote on September 2, 2008 - 7:33 pm | Visit Link

[...] arrested by government agents when he finally arrives in the country anytime this week after being deported from the U.S. (Some reports expect his arrival tomorrow at around 11 p.m. onboard a Northwest [...]

The Daily PCIJ » Blog Archive » Welcome home, Joc-Joc wrote on October 27, 2008 - 10:19 pm | Visit Link

[...] Source : http://www.pcij.org/blog/?p=2357 [...]

? Sekai ?’s World (redundancy…) | What a Joc! (on Joc-Joc Bolante’s case) wrote on December 3, 2008 - 1:09 pm | Visit Link

feel free to leave a comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Best News and Media Blog

About The Daily PCIJ

This is the institutional blog of the Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism.

Philippine ODA Trail: A Journalist's Resource Tool

Get Firefox!
Best viewed with Firefox

News & Journalism - Top Blogs Philippines
This is my Google PageRank™ - SmE Rank free service Powered by Scriptme

The PCIJ Channel
Podcasting from the Philippines
Podcast Feed
Podcast Feed
Feedburner
Feedblitz

Google
Web pcij.org

Categories


Archives



Creative Commons License